David Harfield

A Portfolio

Archive for February, 2009

Album Review

Posted by davidharfield on February 25, 2009

The Amateurs – Homesick EP

Every genre has its leaders, ones whom others will attempt to follow. Every rock guitarist will spend hours at a time perfecting their most authentic Hendrix squeal; every singer-songwriter will leaf through Dylan’s prolific back pages with a magnifying glass, and every showboat front man will not rest until the patented Jagger strut is within their grasp. The problem with emulating leaders in such a potentially vacuous genre as contemporary mainstream pop-rock is that no matter how high you set your sights, you will only ever really be a pale imitation of Coldplay.

Even the band’s name, The Amateurs, does not evoke dizzying levels of innovation, or even high quality, unless its an ironic shield against criticism, (think of the scene in ‘Wayne’s World 2′, where Wayne asks the club’s bouncer, “Who’s playing tonight?”, “The Sh**ty Beatles.” “ Are they any good?”, “ No, they’re pretty sh*t.” “Oh, so it’s not just a clever name…”). The EPs eponymous first track has lead singer Matthew Colley aping Chris Martin’s falsetto warble to a tee amongst enjoyable, yet instantly forgettable guitar licks. Prosaic chord progressions allow the band the room to experiment a little with alternating riffs, while Colley turns in fairly impressive vocal performance that would win the hearts of karaoke queens world-wide.

London Sky’s ramshackle harmonica-intro actually hints at something a little quirky, before lurching into such a direct pastiche of Goo Goo Dolls’ Give a Little Bit that the band should seek professional legal advice.

Mystery Thing is fun in the same way that having a beer at lunchtime is quite fun; a little indulgent, quietly rebellious, but you know that nothing’s really going to happen. It’s piano-driven pop tells a story of a girl that has, “never been to school in her life…she never looks back.” Somewhere there’s a character in a Journey song wishing for a better part.

This all may appear a little harsh; the songs are pleasant enough, the effort is certainly there and if it were 1998 and Dawson’s Creek needed a soundtrack, then The Amateurs may be the band for the job. Regrettably, it is 2009 and we’ve all moved on; The Amateurs will either have to have to catch up and start imitating some true legends or stay peaking at mediocrity.

David Harfield

(http://www.roomthirteen.com/cd_reviews/9693/Amateurs_The__Homesick.html)

Posted in Album Reviews | Tagged: , , , , , | 1 Comment »

No fear of flying high for indie newcomers

Posted by davidharfield on February 21, 2009

Guildean Gang – Dennis Bergkamp

Songs whose titles name football legends of the past have somewhat of a chequered history. The Others’ Stan Bowles sounds like something that Pete Doherty would throw up at the nadir of his crack addiction. Brand New’s serene Me vs. Maradona vs. Elvis is actually quite beautiful, before it becomes clear that the protagonist is casually discussing a date-rape. And don’t even start on Simply the Best

Art-pop youngsters Guildean Gang look to revive this downward trend with their impressive debut single Dennis Bergkamp, a lo-fi anthem in the vein of Interpol, had they come from Bedfordshire, or the Yeah Yeah Yeahs if they just chilled out a little.

An atmospheric drum pattern introduces the track, with a chiming guitar part counting in the stuttering vocal line, infused with a nervous energy that will surely translate contagiously when played live. This leads to an infectiously paranoid chorus, “All the walls are talking, about what they’re watching,” soon to be echoing round the bedrooms of misunderstood indie-kids country-wide. The careful blend of a few contrasting styles, renders Guildean Gang sounding at once like the sum of so many influences and yet like no one else on the current indie soundscape.

The B-side, Tales of the Tree is less innovative, yet still engaging, a sprawling blues-funk jam with a verse faintly evocative of Outkast’s Ms. Jackson. Charlie Stone’s reverb-soaked vocals have a raw, whiskey-ravaged edge, while containing an endearing lisp that belies his tender years, sounding like Tom Waits’ great-great-great-grandson.

Dodgy song titles aside, Guildean Gang look set to score big in the future.

David Harfield

(http://www.roomthirteen.com/cd_reviews/9695/Guildean_Gang__Dennis_Bergkamp.html)

Posted in Single Reviews | Tagged: , , , , | Leave a Comment »

Chicago punk poets prove why they’ll be with us to the end…and then some.

Posted by davidharfield on February 20, 2009

Alkaline Trio – Manchester Academy – 11/02/09

It must be hard to support a band like Alkaline Trio.  Whilst having brief flirtations with the mainstream, the Chicago-based punk threesome have never been a ‘popular’ band, yet over their thirteen years together have accrued a modest legion of hardcore fans who would gladly follow them to Hell and back, and can certainly be relied upon to turn up when they visit their hometown.  In any case, the impatient audience seemed less than impressed with the blend of  dance, rock and funk of warm up act The Audition (a name that invites too many jokes to even bother), with a front man who obviously graduated late from the Jay-Z school of showmanship, hollering, “F**k Yeah!” at any given opportunity.  Think Justin Timberlake singing Taking Back Sunday covers, halve it and you’re nearly there…

After a prolonged interval involving a stage-hogging roadie who insisted on tuning each instrument to a Rain Man-like level of detail, (definitely E-flat, definitely…) the main attraction finally arrived, to the strains of a histrionic string section, before singer/guitarist Matt Skiba’s knife-like chords cut into Agony and Irony‘s opener Calling all Skeletons.  Clad in skin-tight black leather and complete with a bare chest, scrawled tattoos and wraparound sunglasses, Skiba looked every inch the archetypal rock star, wearing his heart and attitude on torn sleeves.  Rushing through a few crowd favourites, the band took a while to find their stride, but when they did it was everything that a punk rock show should be.

With a tightness and cohesive flow that can only be achieved through a decade of sharing a stage, twin vocalists Skiba and Dan Andriano exchanged turns in the spotlight, Andriano’s bellowed crooning the perfect counterpart to Skiba’s triumphant rasp.  Both singers supported each other’s songs with harmonies intricate enough to make Brian Wilson Smile, proving that there’s more to their particular brand of punk-rock than rusty three chord patterns.  Career defining anthem Sadie, a song documenting the true story of a member of Charles Manson’s ill-fated cult, united the arena in awed silence.  Anyone bereft of goose bumps following Skiba’s desolate howl, “the blood they found on you/Charlie’s broken .22”, to the backdrop of genuine tape footage from Sadie Glutz’s interrogation cell should have been discharged from the arena immediately, their punk licence in tatters.

Goodbye Forever was dedicated to, “the late, great Jerry Finn,” the much-revered punk-rock producer who passed away last year and who had collaborated with the band several times, giving their more recent albums a radio-friendlier sheen.  It’s a testament to how little they have compromised their sound that such an old favourite segued so neatly into the more recent Emma.  Detractors from their music would argue that too many songs sound too similar; while it is true that many of the songs begin and end with the full band crashing through a set of power chords, these jibes miss the essence of Alkaline Trio.  This band happily bleeds for their audience, no matter who they are and this is the reason why such a strong contingent of their fan base wear their show of allegiance on ink-stained skin.  The ironic lyrical blend of hope and despair, heartache and joy all coated in irreverent wit and spun amongst a melodic maelstrom of sheer punk rock unites fans from all musical avenues in the celebration of pure ragged emotion and anyone who doesn’t get it, well it’s their loss.

This show of unity was epitomised during the encore, in an achingly intimate version of Blue in the Face; Skiba, framed against the darkness by jagged spotlights, scratchily enquired, “I don’t dream since I quit sleeping and I haven’t slept since I met you….so what do you say, your coffin or mine?”    A band that would happily share eternity with its fans is certainly worth spending a lifetime with.

David Harfield

(http://www.roomthirteen.com/live_reviews/5787/Alkaline_Trio_Alkaline_Trio_S.html)

Posted in Live Reviews | Tagged: , , , , , , | Comments Off

Still burning up a storm, Scottish indie kids provide nonchalant chaos to a welcoming audience.

Posted by davidharfield on February 16, 2009

The View – Manchester Academy 2 – 09/02/09

It’s just not fair. Guitar music is just too good nowadays. Ever since the Arctic Monkeys arrived and blew away any hope for skinny-jeaned indie kids to avoid the workplace for a few years, the bar has been raised to an unreasonable height. Five years ago support act The Last Gang, who looked like Franz Ferdinand on smack and sounded like Scouting For Girls on speed, would have received a modest record deal and would be headlining the Manchester Academy, instead of filling the support slot and hawking their own EPs after the gig. “3 songs, 3 quid…”

One band that did make the cut in that 2005/6 wave of ‘landfill indie’ were Dundee youngsters The View, with their cheery, Libertines-lite debut, Hats off to the Buskers; now they’re back with a follow-up album, Which Bitch, and a tireless touring schedule has kept the indie-rockers very busy indeed. The band that built their reputation on riotous yet joyous performances seem to have lost none of the enthusiasm that got them noticed in the first place; even before they appeared, their vociferous fan base were chanting, “The View, The View, The View are on fire!” and were having so much fun exchanging beer mid-air that the band’s presence seemed almost superfluous. When they did arrive it was to the strains of tuneful feedback, greeting the crowd with a few, “och ayes?“, before tearing into their high-octane indie numbers, with the same confidence, energy and haircuts that they possessed last time around.

Crowd favourites were cherry-picked from their back catalogue, with the pop-tastic Wasted Little DJs being dropped in early on to great applause; dwarfed behind a trademark electric-acoustic guitar and sporting a shock of curls that would put Frank Zappa to shame, frontman Kyle Falconer led his band of (very) merry men through a loose but practiced set, punctuating the tunes with a kind of melodic rambling, all coated in a thick Dundee accent. Perhaps in the spirit of the ramshackle jam session that was the latter half of their set, Falconer swapped both instruments and roles with bassist Kieran Webster and let him shout his way through a few punked up tunes; while both charming and entertaining, it was also slightly misjudged, as Falconer’s heavy-handed strumming of the bass transformed the venue into what felt like a Pendulum house party. This laissez-faire attitude is one of the most attractive features of The View and is possibly one of the reasons that they were signed so early on in their career. However, the devil-may-care attitude that brought them this far may prove to be an ironic stumbling block that prevents them from being main players in the UK rock scene.

What prevented the show from being great as opposed to just pretty good was that a few too many of the songs sounded too similar as sections of the set seemed to merge into one another. The fact that Falconer’s idiosyncratic vocal technique rendered the lyrics indecipherable to anyone other than the band’s, (albeit fairly prevalent), fan base did not help matters. Recent single Shock Horror was saved for the finale, complete with a mass sing-along, crowd surfing and some 12A-rated disrobing from the otherwise anonymous drummer. The View may not have the mass appeal of the Arctic Monkeys or indeed their prodigious talent, but their infectiously insouciant anthems coupled with the sheer youthful exuberance of their delivery will surely keep them on the main stage for some time to come…and it’s not like they really care anyway.

David Harfield

(http://www.roomthirteen.com/live_reviews/5786/View_at_The_View_Tour_Spring_2009.html)

Posted in Live Reviews | Tagged: , , , | Leave a Comment »

Middling effort from Stourbridge quartet…indie at its most impressionistic.

Posted by davidharfield on February 16, 2009

Science Vs. Romance – Life Through Your Eyes EP

It’s a telling sign when a new band namecheck another new band as key influences on their musical style; it’s a bit like Emma Watson listing Daniel Radcliffe as her mentor. In any case, when alt-indie kids Science Vs. Romance state that Scottish newcomers Twin Atlantic have had a “closely penned” influence on their music, it hints at shallow creative depths. Life Through Your Eyes is certainly not a bad record; it is entirely listenable from start to finish, with a few peaks and even fewer troughs, yet it is underscored by a youthful naivety that instead of charming listeners simply sedates them into an amiable comfort rather than creating the angsty tension that such maudlin alt-indie music should evoke.

First track Out of Luck has the right idea; a lush delay effect on the lead guitar introduces the song, before chopping at a fairly pedestrian verse which leads to a soaring chorus, with lead singer Matthew Vale, crooning, “All of my best friends, they’re out of touch, and as much I hate to say, I’m out of luck.” Unfortunately, both the lyrics and vocals seem a little rushed, as if they spent all their studio-time perfecting the wonderfully serene lead guitar tone that permeates each song and only had five minutes left on the clock, so Vale banged out a few hackneyed cliches wondering whether to, “cut my hair and get a job.

Black Coffee continues the trend of say-what-you-see lyrics, “Wake up, feel the coffee burn, these caffeine drinks are all I have,” set to a backdrop of delicately picked guitar lines; the formulaic verse-chorus-verse pattern that each song follows does nothing to help the band’s innovational aspirations. (Points for effort should go to Stuart Nicholls for fitting so many different guitar parts into the same 4 chord patterns.) The blend of major-key indie set to heartfelt lyrics may aim for such great heights as The Postal Service, but ends up more Plain White T’s than Death Cab For Cutie.

Standing in the Footsteps of Giants sounds like a slightly mellowed Funeral for a Friend, circa-Hours era and is the EP’s strongest track. It is slightly marred by an ill-judged a cappella mid-section, yet redeemed by a superb anti-chorus and engaging drum fills throughout. 1968 also shows promise, sporting a verbose yet infectious chorus line that sounds as if should be screamed by an emo-core band from Long Beach instead of an indie-rock band from Stourbridge.

It’s not a bad effort for a young band, certainly impressive considering their short time span together; however, they’ve got a lot more work to do before they are named as a key influence by some other upcoming indie kids.

David Harfield

(http://www.roomthirteen.com/cd_reviews/9710/Science_vs_Romance__Life_Through_Your_Eyes.html)

Posted in Album Reviews | Tagged: , , | Leave a Comment »

Pleasant surprise from Dundee indie scamps’ sophomore album.

Posted by davidharfield on February 16, 2009

The View – Shock Horror

With the recession biting everywhere, it seems that even critically acclaimed indie-rockers are getting the blues. Shock Horror, The View’s second single from their upcoming album Which Bitch finds frontman Kyle Falconer in a sombre mood, mumbling a piano-led soliloquy concerning universal worries amongst young men around the world, “The clock keeps ticking/Let’s hope we don’t grow old“. This maudlin introspection doesn’t last long before the rest of the band chime in with an upbeat 2-2 rhythm, complete with a few anthemic “oh oh ohs” to boot, building on the winning formula that made their debut, Hats off to the Buskers such a success amongst inebriated students and music industry bigwigs alike. No concessions are made to mask or even tone down Falconer’s thick Dundee accent, a tack that has the Marmite-esque effect of being either recklessly endearing or annoyingly affected, depending on your personal taste.

The chorus is pure pop in rock’s clothing; the hook, “a little bit of shock shock horror” is as catchy as anything Pete Doherty, (the band’s alleged idol) ever slurred out with either of his infamous outfits. However, while the single is great for sing-along joviality, it possesses none of the sleazy yet enigmatically attractive allure of Doherty’s underworld chic, the peek through the door of the wild and arcadian houses of The Libertines and Babyshambles. Perhaps this is the prudent choice for The View’s career longevity, not to mention health and legal repercussions, yet it could prevent them from being ranked amongst rock’s true wild ones. Still, good album sales will help stave off those recession blues…

David Harfield

(http://www.roomthirteen.com/cd_reviews/9721/View__Shock_Horror.html)

Posted in Single Reviews | Tagged: , , , , | Leave a Comment »

Cool and credible pop-rock debut from Scandinavian indie queen. Edgy enough for students, safe enough for mums.

Posted by davidharfield on February 6, 2009

Ida Maria – Fortress ’round My Heart

The fact that Perez Hilton has taken time out of his busy schedule of Britney-bashing to label Ida Maria, “our new obsession,” may seem something of a poisoned chalice, but Norway’s latest indie-pop export is not complaining. The re-release of her debut album Fortress ’round My Heart has clearly cornered the market in paunchy, malevolent celeb-bloggers, but on the strength of her high-energy, engagingly sincere debut album, hopefully Maria can set her sights on a better class of fan.

Recent singles Oh My God and I Like You So Much Better When You’re Naked posit Maria to be the rather talented daughter of the Ting Tings and Kaiser Chiefs, (it often skips a generation…) but these are only pop-reared Trojan horses, aimed at sneaking a credible indie album into her listeners’ playlists.

Queen of the World is a joyous anthem celebrating the blithe nihilism of youth, a culture that forgets yesterday and knows no tomorrow. This glorious stomp-rocker possesses an inherent ebullience that transcends age and gender; it will surely have cohorts of busy mums and University rugby teams spinning round in supermarkets and bars respectively, proclaiming that they are the queens of their own little worlds. Stella’s hoarse chorus finds Maria doing her best Marlon Brando, screaming the song’s title at the top of B&H sponsored lungs; her husky, guttural vocal style set to a sunshine pop-rock backdrop has Maria sounding like Nico, if she had met Brian Wilson instead of Lou Reed.

Being a female singer-songwriter in the indie-pop mould, comparisons between Maria and Alanis Morissette are inevitable. However, whereas Morissette’s faux-poetic ranting about life’s big issues often alienate the majority of the population that aren’t single, bored and lonely young women, Fortress ’round My Heart’s simple adolescent lyrical themes have a curiously ubiquitous appeal to them, with anyone from 16 to 60 able to relate to Maria’s songs. (Now isn’t that ironic…?)

Ballads are Maria’s weak point, with both Leave Me, Let Me Go and In the End both dragging a little, yet they are cleverly interspersed amongst the up-tempo rock songs, so as not to bore the listener. Superb album finale We’re All Going To Hell echoes Bright Eyes’ Laura Laurant, with Maria playing conductor to a rag-tag choir of friends, infectiously harmonising on the song’s title; never has eternal damnation sounded so much fun.

Fortress ’round My Heart will tap into the teen inside you, no matter what your age. The contagious ‘girl-indie’ tunes will stay in your head for days on end, yet unlike the barging intrusion of Kate Nash and Lily Allen’s bubble-gum tripe, Ida Maria’s songs will be a welcome guest.

David Harfield

(http://www.roomthirteen.com/cd_reviews/8659/Ida_Maria__Fortress_round_My.html)

Posted in Album Reviews | Tagged: , , , , , , | Leave a Comment »

Sparse, haunting and often beautiful…impressive taster from one-woman Smoke Fairies.

Posted by davidharfield on February 3, 2009

Fran Rodgers – The Green Room EP

From the medieval chord pattern on opening track, The Lighthouse through to the urgent strings on album dénouement The Protester, Fran Rodgers’ debut EP sounds as if it could have been recorded any time in the last five centuries. With the syncopated harmonies and self-styled finger-picking that permeate The Green Room, one can picture the folkie songstress recording the EP in a hut in Sherwood Forest, surviving on leaves and berries like a vegan Bon Iver.

In fact, The Green Room sees Rodgers following up the success of her recent single and performances at Leeds and Reading festivals last summer and is set for release in late February. Her folk-tinged melodies carry the stories of love, loss and hope over a harmonious blend of acoustic guitars and subtle percussion, evoking comparisons with Beth Orton and Mary Black. Lyrically, Rodgers often leans on metaphors, in particular the nautical theme that runs throughout A Place to Lay Your Head, with a siren-like vocal quality drawing the listener into her ageless world of beauty and despair.

Wild Beasts’ Tom Fleming provides backing vocals that balance Rodgers’ shrill melodies on I See Horses Flee, hauntingly chanting, “They’ll be tears tonight, in this quiet town”; the lyrics denote Rodgers’ provincial upbringing in Nottinghamshire and is the EP’s gentle summit.

The strength of The Green Room’s songs lies in their simplicity; whether this could hold the listener for an entire album remains to be seen, yet with female electro-pop tipped to be what’s hot in 2009, artists like Rodgers and Smoke Fairies seem to be the perfect antidote to Lady GaGa and her ilk.

David Harfield

(http://www.roomthirteen.com/cd_reviews/9694/Fran_Rodgers__The_Green_Room_EP.html)

Posted in Album Reviews | Tagged: , , , , | Leave a Comment »

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.